Visit Celestina's column >>

CELESTINAHome Page

SURREALISM: You have two giraffes. The government requires you to take harmonica lessons.
Add To Watchlist
Articles Posted: 134; Links Seeded: 164
Member Since: 2/2006

Assignment Zero : Crowdsourced Novels Roll Call!

Does it have to be this way? My experience tells me "YES!", but I could be wrong...

advertisement

Now that the commotion around the introduction of the Newsvine/Assignment Zero cooperative journalism project has died down a bit, it is time for everyone to 'fess up to exactly what they are willing to give to the project. Mykola is point person for Crowdsourced Nonfiction, Adam Hobson has assumed the role of fearless leader on Crowdfunding, and I will be heading up the effort for Crowdsourced Novels. Who wants to help?

The idea behind the Crowdsourced Novels project is that while traditionally creative writing efforts have taken place in private, with one (probably drunk, inevitably dying) misunderstood genius slaving away behind closed doors day and night until the final product can be ripped to shreds in a fit of pique and painstakingly pieced together by their great-nephew so that the writer's genius can be realized many years after their demise, these days it doesn't have to work like that. With so many people able to find community online, and with the ease of collaboration, even across great distances, writing together can become a satisfying and productive effort.

That's the theory. The question which we must explore is whether it can be effectively done, or whether a meshing of truly creative minds is doomed from the start.

The AZ website gives our starting point as A Million Penguins, a crowdsourced novel. This project started in January and appears to have wrapped up recently. Other related efforts are Exit Strategy, written by Douglas Rushkoff, but left up online for a year so that anyone could add footnotes and annotations, These Wicked Games, a romance novella ebook in which multiple writers submitted chapters, The Open Source Novel, which is an online open work of fiction with over 200 authors, and the one-time project Smart Genes, which seems to have disappeared from the web. Are there other online collaborative efforts just waiting to be discovered? Seems like there must be...

Also springing to my mind are the Known Space series by Larry Niven, which he later opened up to other authors, and Robert Asprin's Thieves' World in which many authors played off each others' stories in order to create a comprehensive fictional world. Does anyone know of any other print precursors to the current online trend?

What we need right now are a bunch of people willing to spend some time investigating these various angles. Any research or interviews you do can be published to your own column, first and foremost, and you will also be given credit in the final article for any work you put into this. I, for one, am really curious to see the answer to the question of whether creative authors can work effectively together. Will you come help?

  • 35 Votes
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.

Back To Top

Published to:

What's this?
Who's leading the conversation?
This visualization below allows you to see the impact that each user has on the current conversation. The top row contains the group of users who have had the most impact, the 2nd row the group of users who have had the 2nd most impact (et cetera). Users with similar impact are grouped together, and the average score of the group is shown to the left of the group. The author of the article is also shown on the left, in their corresponding group. Each user's score is based on the number of comments the user has made plus the number of votes their comments have received. The scores are calculated relative one another, so while their absolute value is not particularly important, their relative difference does indicate a larger difference in impact on the conversation.
12
5.3
3.1
Jump to discussion page: 1 2
{"commentId":598452,"authorDomain":"vikibabbles"}

I'd like to help, Celestina, but right now my workload for school is huge. Supposedly, I'm getting two masters degrees by mid-May. Can I crowd-source my fictional thesis AND my pedagogy paper? ;)

My time would allow for editing of written work, however. I'd be happy to look over anyone's articles and edit for clarity, spelling/grammar, etc.

I haven't even taken enough time to see exactly how this all should work. Should I edit on the AZ end, or on the Newsvine end? I don't know!

This crowd-sourced novel idea intrigues me, mostly because right now I am scoffing at it, and I'd like to see if my opinion could be changed on the subject.

{"commentId":598452,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"vikibabbles"}
  • 4 votes
Reply#1 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 10:20 AM EDT
{"commentId":598470,"authorDomain":"deatienza"}

The concept of crowdsourced novels reminds me of sitting around a campfire as a kid passing the flashlight, and every person you pass it to adds to the next part of the story.

A case can also be made for crowdsourced mythology surrounding the Star Wars expanded universe books. Each author that writes a novel (or trilogy of novels) in that series adds to the fabric of the universe and each subsequent authors must write their novels to fit into the worlds created by the people who wrote before them.

The same thing works in comics, as in the DC or Marvel universe (with some exceptions) all of their titles exist with each other and there must be continuity between all of the series. And each comic series in itself is written by a slew of different authors.

{"commentId":598470,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"deatienza"}
  • 4 votes
#1.1 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 10:25 AM EDT
{"commentId":598507,"authorDomain":"vikibabbles"}

Great analogy with the campfire, Eric. I see it in much the same way. My questions and hesitation on it have to do with attribution, and this is much the same issue I have with the AZ project as a whole--I'm a narcissist. I want my name and my name only on the cover of the book. Do I need to get over that? Possibly. That's why I'm intrigued by this project. Argh!

{"commentId":598507,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"vikibabbles"}
  • 2 votes
#1.2 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 10:36 AM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":598577,"authorDomain":"farmer"}

Celestina, as we have discussed by email I am on your team. I am ready to go. I am involved with other projects on AZ and elsewhere but my duty is to you first. I want to learn as much as I can because one of these days I want to publish the epic literary historical novel of the 20th Century and I want to do it before the 21st is over. My participation in our AZ project should help.

Mykola, Adam, when you snooze you lose. When Celestina gets through with me maybe she will pass me on to those we have left behind and you can take advantage of me then.

{"commentId":598577,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"farmer"}
  • 4 votes
Reply#2 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 11:05 AM EDT
{"commentId":599740,"authorDomain":"davidmcgirr"}

Can I be on the team in some form or fashion?

-Dave

{"commentId":599740,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"davidmcgirr"}
  • 3 votes
#2.1 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 7:42 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":598623,"authorDomain":"thevineofhob"}
Other related efforts are Exit Strategy, written by Douglas Rushkoff, but left up online for a year so that anyone could add footnotes and annotations

Even though I'm working on the crowdfunding aspect, there was another project on just Rushkoff involving interviewing him. Since I've read quite a few of his books, I applied for that task and was accepted. So if you have a question or two that you'd like to ask him on the crowdsourcings novels aspect then let me know.

{"commentId":598623,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"thevineofhob"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#3 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 11:22 AM EDT
{"commentId":598654,"authorDomain":"ForestBrowne"}

Celestina...I like Vicki feel a certain trepidation when confronted with sharing creative and logical thoughts as pertains to writing. I can handle an editor, but am not at all sure I take instruction well, hence would probably would be of little use unless alpha dog defense mechanisms would be in order.

I have empirically commented once or twice in the AZ threads just to keep track, but am not sure at all I would be helpful except in an analytical sort of way.

Forest

{"commentId":598654,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"ForestBrowne"}
  • 3 votes
Reply#4 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 11:34 AM EDT
{"commentId":600794,"authorDomain":"celestina"}

Well, one appealing thing about this project is that to a large extent you can work under your own auspices. We have a list of related topics that need to be investigated, and at the end of the research phase we will do our best to compile them into one, comprehensive article. If you are interested, I would love for you to participate, but I do understand your hesitation. Please just let me know if you decide you do want to work on an angle of this, and otherwise I will welcome your help as a constructive critic of both the process and the product.

{"commentId":600794,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"celestina"}
  • 3 votes
#4.1 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 9:15 AM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":598785,"authorDomain":"danCharles"}

Celestina,
Like Forest and Vicki, I have some time constraints, but can certainly help (I have 15-20 college hours that were workshop environments, but that was more than 15 years ago).

If you can use me, I would like to play.

{"commentId":598785,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"danCharles"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#5 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 12:21 PM EDT
{"commentId":598787,"authorDomain":"raatkiraani"}

Celestina,

I have said I am happy to help as editor although I am unsure how the process works. My reservations include:

* what rights do editors have over work they edit (in terms of publishing to own column before public onslaught)?
* where do we work, A-Z or NV?
* what level of time comittment are we looking at? (work schedules are always demanding, especially at present. I need to play a careful balancing act on this one.
* when is an editor likely to come in the fray?

{"commentId":598787,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"raatkiraani"}
  • 3 votes
Reply#6 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 12:22 PM EDT
{"commentId":600279,"authorDomain":"celestina"}

In your first question, are you asking whether others (the editors) can publish others' work (with their edits) to their own column, or whether you can publish your own work as you see fit (regardless of what editors may recommend)?

As for where you work, I think we definitely need a base of operations here for the organizing and compilation of our work here, but the AZ team encourages everyone to put up as much of their work over there as they can, as well. They really want a large part of their experiment to be about having an open dialogue as the end result is being created.

You can choose as small or as large a piece of this as you want. The deadlines as I have been given them are: a week from Friday for research to be completed, and two weeks later for the final article (or articles).

I am not sure about the editor question. I am sending them an email tonight with some questions, and I will include that in the list.

Thanks for the willingness to help, and I will get back to you with more definitive answers as soon as I know them.

{"commentId":600279,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"celestina"}
  • 1 vote
#6.1 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 11:36 PM EDT
{"commentId":600884,"authorDomain":"raatkiraani"}

Thanks Celestina.

are you asking whether others (the editors) can publish others' work (with their edits) to their own column,

Yes, that's the question. If I come aboard as an editor, can I post any piece that I have edited in my own column? What this could mean is that a writer and editor (even many to many) may potentially post their pieces, albeit with subtle variations. The Vine could become awful crowded as a result!

{"commentId":600884,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"raatkiraani"}
  • 2 votes
#6.2 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 9:45 AM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":598989,"authorDomain":"whatwasleft"}

I'm in. What needs doing?

{"commentId":598989,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"whatwasleft"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#7 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 1:49 PM EDT
{"commentId":598996,"authorDomain":"SimplyTRUE"}

Celestina,

Like the others, I have some stuff going on that limits my time. But, I don't want to miss the opportunity to work with the great talent that has already signed on, so count me in. This is a great opportunity to experience this literary process and I look forward to working with your team.

{"commentId":598996,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"SimplyTRUE"}
  • 4 votes
Reply#8 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 1:51 PM EDT
{"commentId":599010,"authorDomain":"cha-robertson"}

I think the failing point of crowdsourced novels is who the royalties go to once the book becomes a best seller.

{"commentId":599010,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"cha-robertson"}
    Reply#9 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 1:56 PM EDT
    {"commentId":599051,"authorDomain":"yasmin"}

    Count me in on Editing and Research.

    I have some time. I'm doing the whole job-hunting right now, so my time constraints are minimal. I'm mostly busy in the afternoons/evenings.

    {"commentId":599051,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"yasmin"}
    • 2 votes
    Reply#10 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 2:10 PM EDT
    {"commentId":599106,"authorDomain":"farmer"}

    Robie, I am with you but I would point something out. If a bunch of people write a novel and a bunch of people get it published there is a very good chance of it getting published. The chances of it making money are slim but still, no one person would be out a life time by contributing. I am sure that if these kind of things become popular, those that participate will receive benefits or revenue.

    {"commentId":599106,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"farmer"}
    • 2 votes
    Reply#11 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 2:30 PM EDT
    {"commentId":599309,"authorDomain":"cha-robertson"}

    well pointed out oldfogey I went to have a look at what its all about, but can't seem to grasp how it all stays organised but i'll continue to check. maybe one day i'll get it.

    {"commentId":599309,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"cha-robertson"}
    • 1 vote
    #11.1 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 3:38 PM EDT
    {"commentId":599896,"authorDomain":"vikibabbles"}

    Good point, Jerry.

    It should be about more than making money. It should be about crafting a quality piece of writing. I just find it so hard to believe that's possible with a gazillion random contributors!

    And, I'm a narcissistic control freak. That might have something to do with it.

    {"commentId":599896,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"vikibabbles"}
      #11.2 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 9:17 PM EDT
      Reply
      {"commentId":599137,"authorDomain":"smackcover"}

      I will help, but please direct me as to how to begin investigating these things. Do I search for collaborative efforts and then report on them or interview a couple of the authors? What?

      {"commentId":599137,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"smackcover"}
      • 2 votes
      Reply#12 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 2:41 PM EDT
      {"commentId":599247,"authorDomain":"danCharles"}

      Here are a couple of quick leads.
      A print collaborative book called Naked Came the Manatee - thirteen authors include Carl Hiaassen, Elmore Leonard, and Dave Barry.

      Orson Scott Card's Hatrack River website has a writing workshop that could make for a sound starting point. (Card does a fair amount of collaborative work, so this sight might be handy.)

      {"commentId":599247,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"danCharles"}
      • 2 votes
      Reply#13 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 3:15 PM EDT
      {"commentId":599749,"authorDomain":"economist"}
      BartlebyDeleted
      {"commentId":599763,"authorDomain":"farmer"}

      There is always somebody who can find something to crow about.

      {"commentId":599763,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"farmer"}
      • 1 vote
      Reply#15 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 7:57 PM EDT
      {"commentId":599772,"authorDomain":"economist"}
      BartlebyDeleted
      Reply
      {"commentId":600011,"authorDomain":"Shibbolith"}

      Celestina,

      Great idea and I would like to be involved.

      I came across a novel some years ago while in Paris called "Yeats is Dead". It was a collaborative effort by, if memory serves, about a dozen or so writers each one contributing a single chapter.

      I remember it so clearly because I am big Roddy Doyle fan and he did the opening chapter.

      In that case the writers must have all been across a general plot outline to begin with but you can tell in the reading of it that the story took on a life of it's own during the writing and the result was outstanding.

      It was an effort for charity and as I recall really funny.

      Here is a link:

      http://www.amazon.com/Yeats-Dead-Mystery-Irish-Writers/dp/0375727566

      WS

      {"commentId":600011,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"Shibbolith"}
      • 1 vote
      Reply#16 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 9:58 PM EDT
      {"commentId":600175,"authorDomain":"PrimarySources"}

      Celestina, while offering up the usual caveats about "busy--blah, blah, blah", this sounds like an aspect of Assignment Zero I too would like to get involved with, whether from the editing or writing sides. Please count me in; I'm not too worried about issues like credit and royalties, so abuse me as you will.

      {"commentId":600175,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"PrimarySources"}
      • 1 vote
      Reply#17 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 10:56 PM EDT
      {"commentId":600242,"authorDomain":"celestina"}

      Thanks, everyone, for coming forward and offering to help. Sorry I have been unable to return to this article today before now (it's a long story), but for now let's start with everyone who offered research abilities taking one of the aspects listed in the article above, or one of the other possibilities listed in the comment thread (in comments #16, 13, and 3 -- tell me if I missed one, I am positively bleary-eyed, typing this). Ideally, I think we want to explore this from as many angles as possible, and I personally would like some interviews with people who have worked first hand on this type of project to know what their experience of it was. We will also need an outline of each effort, including how it came about, who participated, how long it ran and what, if any guidelines they operated under, and an evaluation (or several) of the results. Anything else we should be looking for?

      We can still look for other examples, as well, but we have only a limited about of time to get our research together (we need the research done by a week from Friday), so let's start with what we have here. We definitely need someone to cover A Million Penguins, and as many of the others as we can get to. Please sign up for a branch which interests you, and ask any questions you have as you go along in this column. Also make sure you have checked out AZ's website (linked in the article) as some of your questions may be answered in looking through there. Whatever's left I will do my best to answer as quickly as possible.

      The nature of this project is to be as open and collaborative as possible, so please don't hesitate to make suggestions or ask for advice or take your research off on a tangent which seems interesting and applicable to you. As for the editing process, I am not 100% sure how and when they want us to implement that, so I will send them an email and get back to you as soon as I know.

      {"commentId":600242,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"celestina"}
        Reply#18 - Wed Mar 21, 2007 11:21 PM EDT
        {"commentId":600531,"authorDomain":"sheep"}

        Celestina, et al: Sorry I'm late into this discussion, but a couple of aspects of this topic occurred to me as I was reading some of the responses. First was the mention of Naked Came the Manatee by Barry, Hiaasen and a bunch of other Miami Herald writers. That book was actually a "reply" to a much earlier book, the 1969 novel, Naked Came the Stranger by Penelope Ashe.

        Ashe was actually the pseudonym of columnist Mike McGrady and 20 other writers at the Long Island newspaper Newsday. They decided that culture was so degraded, that even a crappy book could sell well if there was enough sex in it -- something which is pretty much taken for granted today. They each wrote a chapter, editing it to remove any cohesive plot, good dialogue or skilled craftsmanship and watched as it sold incredibly well, even making the New York Times bestseller list. They outed themselves on David Frost's show and later on, McGrady wrote a book about the experience called Stranger Than Naked: Or, How to Write Dirty Books for Fun and Profit: A Manual. One interesting aspect is that McGrady's papers and correspondence with the other authors, along with drafts and manuscripts were all donated and are catalogued at Columbia University, home of the main folks behind AZ. I wish I had the time to go up there and look through the papers, but if the research is due next Friday, that ain't gonna happen. :(

        One other thing this reminded me of was the Surrealist's game of "Exquisite Corpse" which was about creating a short poem or graphic by having each person in a group append a phrase or part of a sketch to an unseen prior phrase or drawing. There's a pretty good Internet version of the text game here and a graphic one here.

        I'm not exactly sure yet of how this whole AZ thing works, but I'm going to post this comment over there in the comments box on the assignments page for "What are other crowdsourced novels?"

        {"commentId":600531,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"sheep"}
        • 4 votes
        Reply#19 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 3:01 AM EDT
        {"commentId":600797,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

        I can help in any of the following ways: Editing/proofreading (I work best when bribed with
        chocolate, for the record)
        coaching writers and helping people prepare for interviews

        I can write too but would rather let some others get that opportunity becaues after writing 10 articles a week for 10 years, well, it's someone else's turn

        {"commentId":600797,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
        • 2 votes
        Reply#20 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 9:17 AM EDT
        {"commentId":600844,"authorDomain":"celestina"}

        OK, here's a quick morning rundown of where we are, along with a little new info I have from AZ.

        Folks who have thus far offered to participate:

        Writing/Research: Oldfogey
        yasmin
        Samantha Gluck
        Synthesis
        Shibbolith
        Dan Charles

        Editing: Vikibabbles
        Raat ki Raani
        Bartleby
        Synthesis
        yasmin

        Unspecified: David McGirr
        whatwasleft
        Orlando Dozier

        Not Sure: Forest Brown
        Eric Atienza
        evano
        (Eric and evano are listed here because I am not sure whether you guys were offering to help, or not...though I sure hope you were!)

        David, whatwasleft, and Orlando, I think we are really going to need all the help we can get covering the research and writing on this thing, so please consider lending your talents there. Those of you who have already offered to be in on the research/writing phase, please pick an aspect of this project today and go ahead and start running down as much information as you can, as per my post last night.

        As far as editing, we definitely need to do our own in-house editing before we send the final product(s) on to AZ at the final deadline. It is up to us how we go about that. I am going to suggest as a starting point that everyone effectively research and write up their own article about their branch of this topic, and then pass it over to an editor before posting it up here (and hopefully on AZ, as well). We will also definitely need a lot of editor input when it comes to preparing the final project.

        I am going to have to be away from the computer for several hours today, but Oldfogey has promised to check in and try to answer any questions you guys have. Anything he can't answer, I will be back on duty this evening.

        {"commentId":600844,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"celestina"}
        • 2 votes
        Reply#21 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 9:33 AM EDT
        {"commentId":602023,"authorDomain":"vikibabbles"}

        Sounds good, Celestina. If anyone wants to email me their article for editing input, you can send it to my regular email address: vikibabbles at gmail.com.

        I will be out of town, but I will access the internet as often as possible and get things back to you ASAP.

        {"commentId":602023,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"vikibabbles"}
        • 3 votes
        #21.1 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 4:00 PM EDT
        {"commentId":602026,"authorDomain":"sheep"}

        Certainly am volunteering! I can run with the stuff I started digging up already, or... one thing that looks like it may be missing or un-stated in the topics is a history of the idea of writing being a solitary endeavor, and the genealogy of the multiple-author/ crowdsourced/ open source work of literature.

        As far as an example of successful crowdsourced literature -- and without meaning to insult anyone -- the Judeo-Christian Bible is a collaborative document, with parts written by different authors and parts sewn together by different editors. It's even more intertwined than a novel where each writer takes on a different chapter, because very often, each verse in some chapters has a different, uncredited author. And... I think we'd have to call the Bible "pretty successful," wouldn't you? :)

        If anyone thinks this is a valuable avenue to pursue, I'm on it. If not, let me know where I could be more useful.

        {"commentId":602026,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"sheep"}
        • 2 votes
        #21.2 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 4:01 PM EDT
        {"commentId":602056,"authorDomain":"celestina"}

        Viki--
        Great! Thanks a bunch.

        evano--
        Glad to have you onboard. I love the idea of using the Bible as an example. Brilliant. Perhaps that can be incorporated into an overall history of collaborative fiction efforts. If you want it, go with it!! I can't wait to see what you come up with.

        {"commentId":602056,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"celestina"}
        • 1 vote
        #21.3 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 4:17 PM EDT
        Reply
        {"commentId":600866,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

        Just kidding. Have a nice computer break. I'm about to take one too.
        Well, I'm taking the laptop to bed with me but with the cable modem unplugged.

        {"commentId":600866,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
        • 2 votes
        Reply#22 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 9:41 AM EDT
        {"commentId":601999,"authorDomain":"celestina"}

        You really have to think about our changing definitions when "taking a computer break" means you just disconnect it from the internet! *grin*

        Thanks for offering to help. We'll add you to the list for editing and proofreading.

        {"commentId":601999,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"celestina"}
        • 1 vote
        #22.1 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 3:51 PM EDT
        Reply
        {"commentId":600967,"authorDomain":"SimplyTRUE"}

        Celestina,

        You can put me down for writing/research. thanks.

        {"commentId":600967,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"SimplyTRUE"}
        • 2 votes
        Reply#23 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 10:17 AM EDT
        {"commentId":601130,"authorDomain":"farmer"}

        Just checking in for Celestina and making sure every one is working. I will be checking in a few times today. Celestina is in dispose for a few hours.

        {"commentId":601130,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"farmer"}
        • 1 vote
        Reply#24 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 11:04 AM EDT
        {"commentId":602043,"authorDomain":"celestina"}

        All right, which of you writers/researchers wants what? The starting list of topics we need to investigate includes:

        A Million Penguins

        Exit Strategy

        Open Source Novel

        These Wicked Games

        Smart Genes

        Yeats is Dead

        Naked Came the Manatee

        Theive's World

        Hatrack River Writers Workshop (which is not a crowdsourced novel, but is an open forum of sorts for editing and feedback on writing)

        Whomever takes Exit Strategy and Open Source Novel should bear in mind Adam's offer in comment #3, above.

        Please let us know what most interests you and see how much you can dig up on it. Who knows, this could lead to an interview with one of your favourite authors! Also, if you have ideas for other angles which may be related, feel free to put them up here. I would hate for this to turn into a project where anyone is just slaving away on something which doesn't interest them.

        {"commentId":602043,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"celestina"}
        • 1 vote
        Reply#25 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 4:13 PM EDT
        {"commentId":602121,"authorDomain":"economist"}
        BartlebyDeleted
        {"commentId":602207,"authorDomain":"sheep"}

        Former English teacher carrying on the proud Internet tradition of never letting a grammar mistake pass without comment. :)

        Bartleby, our volunteer scrivener, is correct on the spelling of Asprin's title for his series, however, the possessive apostrophe is in the wrong place in both versions. "Thieves" is the plural of "thief" and the possessive of a word ending in "s" is formed by placing the apostrophe after the final "s". The correct title should be "Thieves' World." There are opinions on both sides as to whether or not the apostrophe following a final "s" should be followed by another "s" to maintain consistency with most other possessives. I am with the side that says that doing anything solely for the sake of maintaining consistency is silly in a language which contains such inconsistencies as removing the apostrophe from the possessive of "it".

        In a strict prescriptive sense, Bartleby is also correct about the disagreement between "anyone" and "them" in the sentence he parses. However -- you knew there was going to be a "however," didn't you? :) -- "anyone" is a strange word in that it is formed as a singular, but it actually refers to an unspecified subgroup of a larger whole. The word used to describe a specific unknown person is "someone." The different usages are exemplified in the following sentence: "Anyone can correct grammar, but someone is a real pedant who spends three paragraphs correcting a correction."

        Sorry about the insecurities... :) For what it's worth, I'd be very surprised if I didn't make a grammatical mistake in here somewhere.

        {"commentId":602207,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"sheep"}
        • 3 votes
        #25.2 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 5:20 PM EDT
        {"commentId":602247,"authorDomain":"celestina"}

        Bless you both.

        {"commentId":602247,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"celestina"}
        • 2 votes
        #25.3 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 5:41 PM EDT
        {"commentId":602340,"authorDomain":"danCharles"}

        Since I posted Naked Came the Manatee and the Hatrack workshop, I can do one or both. Just let me know what works for y'all.

        {"commentId":602340,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"danCharles"}
        • 1 vote
        #25.4 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 6:22 PM EDT
        {"commentId":603228,"authorDomain":"celestina"}

        Dan--
        Why don't you start with Naked Came the Manatee, and if you have time cover the Hatrack workshop as well.

        Anyone else? We have one week to complete our research. Put your name down for something and see how far you can get.

        {"commentId":603228,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"celestina"}
        • 1 vote
        #25.5 - Fri Mar 23, 2007 9:34 AM EDT
        {"commentId":603284,"authorDomain":"danCharles"}

        I'm on it!

        {"commentId":603284,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"danCharles"}
          #25.6 - Fri Mar 23, 2007 10:09 AM EDT
          Reply
          {"commentId":602349,"authorDomain":"montanus"}
          montanusDeleted
          {"commentId":602419,"authorDomain":"montanus"}
          montanusDeleted
          {"commentId":602442,"authorDomain":"Shibbolith"}

          Celestina,

          I will take Yeats is Dead. I am familiar with some of the writers and I have (limited) access to the literary scene in Dublin.

          I will start to dig into the "Collaborative Experience" the contributors had during the writing of the book and see what I can turn up.

          Thanks
          WS

          {"commentId":602442,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"Shibbolith"}
          • 1 vote
          Reply#28 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 7:24 PM EDT
          {"commentId":602596,"authorDomain":"Shibbolith"}

          Anyone care to join me on this one?

          {"commentId":602596,"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113","authorDomain":"Shibbolith"}
            #28.1 - Thu Mar 22, 2007 9:12 PM EDT
            Reply
            Jump to discussion page: 1 2
            {"canLink":false,"threadId":"86720","isPrivate":false}
            Leave a Comment:
            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
            {"threadId":"86720","contentId":"625113"}
            Start TrackingStart Tracking
            Stop TrackingStop Tracking